Best Medicare Advantage plan for a Part B premium giveback in Navajo County, Arizona

Why this plan

2 of the 7 plans we compare here give back part of your Part B premium. Wellcare Giveback (HMO) gives back the most: $29 a month, $348 over a year. The next is HumanaChoice H5216-263 (PPO), at $1 a month back.

It gives back $336 a year more than HumanaChoice H5216-263 (PPO), but its out-of-pocket limit is $3,800 higher. If you're likely to need much care, the extra giveback could be outweighed in a single year.

What it gives up

• Its out-of-pocket limit, $9,250, is higher than most here (the middle plan's is $5,900): in a year with a lot of care, it could cost you more than other plans.

Who it suits

A giveback suits you if you pay your own Part B premium and use little care: it lowers the Part B premium taken from your Social Security payment, or billed to you, by the same amount every month. If Medicaid or a Medicare Savings Program pays your Part B premium, a giveback gives you nothing. It can take a few months to start showing up after you join.

More on what a giveback is really worth, and when it isn't: Easy Point After or Hail Mary? What Medicare Advantage's Part B Giveback Really Gets You.

The next best for a Part B premium giveback

Before you choose

• Check your doctors and hospitals. Most Medicare Advantage plans pay only, or mostly, for care in their own network. Ask the plan, or your doctor's office, before you join.
• Price your prescriptions. What your drugs cost can differ by hundreds of dollars a year between plans and outweigh any premium difference. Add them in our plan list to see your own costs.
• Read the plan's own documents. We take every figure from what the plan filed with Medicare, but its Evidence of Coverage is the final word on what it pays.
• Get free advice if you want it. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) gives free, unbiased help choosing a plan.

How we picked

The plan that gives back the most of your Part B premium each month. Where several tie, we look next at the lowest out-of-pocket limit for in-network care, then the lowest premium, then the lowest copay to see a primary care doctor. Plans that still tie are listed by name.

We compare the 8 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage that anyone with Medicare in Navajo County can join. Special needs plans and PACE, which are only for people who qualify, aren't included; you'll find them on the Navajo County page. No plan pays to be picked.

We don't pick plans Medicare rates below 3 stars, and leave 1 out here: HumanaChoice R7220-002 (Regional PPO) (2.5 stars). Plans too new to have a rating are included, and say so.