Colorado › Cheyenne County › Best plans

Lowest-priced Medigap Plan G in Cheyenne County, Colorado

For people keeping Original Medicare. Prices as Medicare publishes them, at age 65.

High-deductible Plan G: you pay the first $2,950 in 2026

Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company (Preferred)

Lowest premium $45.86 a month

A preferred rate: only if you pass the company's health questions.

18 companies sell High-deductible Plan G here, from $46–$112/mo.

The next lowest

  • Bankers Life (Underwritten by Washington National Insurance Company): $47.07 a month
  • Humana (Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois, Inc.): $51.10 a month
  • HealthSpring Insurance Company: $57.62 a month
  • Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company (Standard): $57.70 a month

Plan G

Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company (Preferred)

Lowest premium $127.65 a month

A preferred rate: only if you pass the company's health questions.

33 companies sell Plan G here, from $128–$790/mo.

The next lowest

  • Physicians Select Insurance Company (Innovative): $158.29 a month
  • LifeShield National Insurance Company: $159.70 a month
  • Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company (Standard): $161.14 a month
  • Old Surety Life Insurance Company: $169.56 a month

Why these two

Plan G pays everything Original Medicare leaves you owing for covered care except the Part B deductible, with any doctor or hospital in the country that takes Medicare. Every company's Plan G covers exactly the same things, so the price is the difference. The lowest at 65 in Colorado is $127.65 a month, from Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company (Preferred), out of 33 companies selling it. A preferred rate: only if you pass the company's health questions.

High-deductible Plan G is the same coverage once you've paid $2,950 in 2026 yourself, so it costs much less each month: the lowest at 65 is $45.86, from Atlantic Capital Life Assurance Company (Preferred). A preferred rate: only if you pass the company's health questions.

Taking the lowest price for each, the high-deductible plan costs $981 less a year. Under either you pay the Part B deductible; under the high-deductible plan you also pay what comes after it, up to the plan's deductible. So it comes out ahead in a year your costs past the Part B deductible stay under about $981, and behind in a year they go past it, as one hospital stay's deductible usually does.

These are the prices Medicare publishes for ZIP code 80202. A company can charge differently elsewhere in the state, so check the price for your own ZIP code before you apply.

Before you choose

  • Apply in your open enrollment period if you can. For six months from the month you're 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, a company can't turn you down or charge you more because of your health. After that, in most states, it can.
  • Some of the lowest prices need good health. A price marked "Preferred" or similar is a company's rate for applicants who pass its health questions; others pay its standard rate.
  • The cheapest at 65 isn't always the cheapest later. Most companies raise prices as you age, and some raise them faster than others.
  • Add a Part D plan. Medigap doesn't cover prescriptions; you'll want a separate drug plan.

Discussion

Questions and experiences from other visitors. Comment guidelines

Loading the discussion…